Most of AI usage could be easily (with a little bit of effort) replaced by just searching for the info you need, but those days search results are so poor that asking AI gets so advantageous for the average user (that don’t care / don’t know about privacy and other costs and risks that come with it)
Do you think they did it on purpose?
Did they enshittify web search on purpose? Yes, absolutely. There are internal emails from Google proving this. I don’t have the links handy, but dig back through Ed Zitron’s newsletter and he has a very detailed breakdown (www.wheresyoured.at).
Edit - Found the article in question; https://www.wheresyoured.at/the-men-who-killed-google/
Did they do it to boost AI? No, it was already happening. They did it to boost ad revenue. The more pages or searches it takes you to find what you’re looking for, the more ads they get to serve. And the more likely it is that you’ll just give up and take the sponsored links.
AI has further worsened the decline by aiding in the production of low grade content that fills up space, squeezing out the useful stuff you actually want. And driving more use of AI tools certainly gives major players like Microsoft and Google a new, additional incentive to destroy the effectiveness of their search engines. But AI was not the original culprit. The decline started years before ChatGPT.
Yes. This is an open secret.
“Not all of Google’s enshittification can be attributed to deliberate sabotage. Much of it is the result of neglect.” –Cory Doctorow on why Google is an absentee landlord
I’ve also heard Doctorow claim that there were internal emails that came to light during one of Google’s antitrust cases that showed internal arguments at google about whether they should deliberately make search worse.
Why?
Because they have no competitor. If you don’t find what you’re looking for after a search, what do you do next?
Another search. Which means you get to see twice the ads. It was a thoughtful procedure done to increase the number of searches that people do and therefore ad revenue.

