Why is this community suddenly overflowing with AI fanboys? I’m sick of it.
Consider how much money is behind AI right now and it’s a lot easier to understand.
Is the implication here that the AI industry are astroturfing Lemmy/Piefed?
deleted by creator
Its purpose is to replace you
deleted by creator
The word that has been sticking with me about AI is “disrespect.” Disrespect to the training material stolen. Disrespect to the people who wrote it. Disrespect to the communities shouldering the data center load. Disrespect to the people these companies are tracking through their services. Disrespect to authors of websites scraped for data. Disrespect to human intelligence and creativity. Etc.
Everyone I see online hates Ai and everyone I know irl (but my gf) loves it.
Because AI completely destroys online communities but has a much lesser impact on local/IRL communities I suppose. So those depending on online communities a lot are likely geared to be much more adverse to AI.
I don’t hate AI. It’s a tool, I’m indifferent to it. I hate the people trying to force it on everyone and into everything, and their eagerness to fuck up huge numbers of lives to make a quick buck.
A tool has a deterministic outcome, you hammer a nail you know the outcome, you saw a board you know the outcome. No matter how many times you do the same process you know the outcome. Even dice have a boundary of outcomes you can understand.
You give an AI the same string of prompts multiple times and you will get a different outcome each time. Whether its updates to the model or the fact AI’s own response contributes to its context which small changes will build up over time, there is no way of knowing what the outcome will be, how accurate it is, or how to recreate the same results (especially with multiple prompts involved).
I wouldn’t call it a tool for that reason but maybe I am nitpicking here.
Language modeling is equivalent to a dice roll (given a perfect random number generator). Setting the temperature to 0 removes all randomness from the output, meaning the model always selects the highest probability next word, and the model becomes 100% deterministic. That is, the output of a model is entirely predictable given temperature = 0, you know the model weights, and the seed/prompt.
These technicalities aside, it’s true for both a dice roll event and a specific model/prompt event that, practically speaking, the outputs are treated as probabilistic despite being mathematically/technically deterministic: a human can’t predict with 100% accuracy the output of a die despite the theory (classical mechanics of die positioning, force, velocity, friction, …) proving determinism
You know the boundaries of a dice roll based one the number of sides of the dice. You will never know the boundaries of the AI.
With a D20 I know I have a 5% chance of at a roll of 20 and 50% chance to roll over 10. With AI you don’t even know if the data it was trained on was even accurate or if it will hallucinate and speak nonsense.
You can literally ask an AI how many letter Ts are in the word colonialism and it will tell you two. Now how on earth could anyone have known its probability to say that clearly wrong answer?
Also each AI session its response to your prompts contribute to the context of the session and small alterations in how the AI speaks build up and change the outcome of a session, thus the AIs own responses effect its probabilities, another thing you cannot account for.
Yes, you do know the boundaries of AI. It is purely matrix multiplication: its output distribution is just as intelligible as the distribution of rolls of a dice. We receive a probability distribution for the next token given a sequence of tokens. This is demonstrable; search for softmax online.
To fairly equate a dice roll event to a model prompt event we must understand the technicalities. To say you have a 20 sided die, is equivalent to saying you have a specific model’s architecture and value of every parameter, in the context of qualifying event determinism.
If you can assume your die is fair, and 20 sided, that is an equivalent assumption about a model as to saying it’s llama-3.1-8B-instruct. That is, you do know the specific model weights, corresponding to a functional relationship between input and output which is deterministic. That is, if you know the model weights, which is equivalent to knowing whether a die is fair and n-sided, you can deterministically predict the output of a model as you can deterministically predict which number on a die will land
You’re making specific, technical errors about the mathematical basis of language modeling, and equating things fallaciously to a similar deterministic event.
Despite this, your intuition is right: we can’t perceptually predict the output of a model as we can’t perceptually predict what number will result from a die roll
I like parts of AI. I don’t like the video, images, music, etc part that feels dirty and disgusting. Same goes for AI written text 🤮 I like it for coding, and I like it for helping me solve some issues. It’s great for making games run on Linux, I just pass it the terminal error and it helps me solve it fairly fast, ao I dont have to spend time to fix it myself. I just want to play my game.
Its an improved search engine without all the bullshit of scrolling through and reading dozens of websites.
Improved, but also is sometimes wrong, destroys our planet, and tracks everything you do with it.
Don’t forget the part where, in sparing you from reading those sites, it also strips away context clues that might otherwise help you gauge whether it’s a reliable source and whether it even applies to your problem.






