• 0 Posts
  • 17 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 14th, 2023

help-circle







  • The left-right spectrum makes less sense to me by the day.

    However, I personally define tankies as authoritians who do some mental gymnastics to think that a benevolent “socialist” dictatorship equates to control of society by the workers. (It obviously doesn’t. A dictatorship by a minority is exactly that)

    Anyone who defines North Korea as socialist needs to reconsider their political positions, in my opinion.

    Just because they’re in opposition to the capitalist South Korea and the worst imperialist nation in the world, the USA, doesn’t mean you need to stand behind the North Korean regime…

    All the cool socialists think campism is brainrot (my opinion)


  • I suppose we just enjoy different things about Star Wars then, for me it’s all about the world building, and seeing how characters act within it, the battles and action are just a climax to everything else (I feel this way about all sci-fi and fantasy).

    Not saying you only watch it for the battles, but I do mostly watch it for the talking haha

    It’s why I still very much enjoy the prequels, despite them being pretty shoddy on the plot (Anakin’s fall could have been written soooo much better written it hurts. Probably would have needed an extra movie to really sell it though. The Clone Wars TV show episode where Tarkin and Anakin meet for the first time was great if I recall correctly. It made kinda make sense why Anakin bought into fascism in the end.)

    To me there’s no such thing as a food sci-fi and fantasy without politics (in the sense that there’s some disagreement which motivates people). More trade disputes and blockades please, less holdo maneuvers that break existing rules of the world. The holdo maneuver would have been great to destroy the Death Star with some Kamikaze X-Wings jumping to hyperspace through it…

    The battles, to me, are only interesting if one fleshes out the world and the political disagreements.

    I once started watching a Chinese fantasy show (was learning Chinese, and like sci-fi/fantasy) and it opened with a 10 minute battle, no context. Immediately turned it off, like why do I care, show?


  • Ah, I haven’t been keeping up to date! Shall check it out :)

    Not in love with all of Disney star wars, but Andor is hands down the greatest Star Wars I’ve seen, so I’ll forgive them for the rest of the stuff I don’t like as much (not including Star Wars episodes 7-9, straight to jail)


  • I desperately hope you don’t mean episode 9.

    Everyone’s entitled to their own opinion, but damn, do you even like the rest of it? Or other sci-fi and fantasy in general?

    The absolute disrespect of not bothering to try to create a coherent world in episodes 7-9 was staggering.

    If a piece of media’s plot or storytelling is a bit meh, that’s forgivable, but when you’re just straight up not bothering to think of the logistics or established rules within a fantasy/sci-fi world? Please no. Please stop.

    Or at least be writing something supernatural where there are barely any rules and you can hand waive whatever you like.





  • I think perhaps there has been a misunderstanding because I’m saying none of the above are socialist?

    It’s not having it both ways?

    The Nordics are not socialism light. The capitalist class are alive and well there. The workers do not have democratic control over the workplaces (unless they happen to be part of a coop), and you’re still able to amass large amounts of wealth on the backs of the working class (there are billionaires from all those countries).

    I’m not disagreeing that it’s working better than the “hardcore types” (who I’ve just said aren’t socialist). I’d rather live on the Nordics over China, Vietnam, Cuba etc any day…

    I feel like you haven’t actually read my comment :(

    On the other hand, the terrible object lesson examples for socialism litter the history books. I’ll take a soft socialism 5/5 times before gambling with Pol Pot, Stalin, Xi, Kim etc., you do you.

    In name only. In my opinion, if it’s not democratic, it’s not socialism. But I’m kinda annoyed that you’re implying I think those “examples” are something worthwhile…


  • There are non-tankies (me) who just wouldn’t call those countries socialist.

    When asked if there are current examples of socialism working well. Pretty much no, you get couped by the CIA for that haha

    No, I don’t count Cuba, Vietnam, china etc. as socialist.

    You can’t have socialism without democracy, because of, ya know, the whole “worker control” thing…

    I’m most familiar with China, and there they just have an extra aspect of the ruling class which also includes party position, in addition to wealth…

    In conclusion, accurately pointing out that Norway, Sweden and Denmark aren’t socialist, doesn’t mean you’re a tankie.

    They’re just more regulated capitalist countries with better social safety nets than the USA.


  • He’s not very socialist, no. But based on your take that socialists on the west are imperialist simply for existing within an imperialist nation, something tells me you think anyone who’s the enemy of the USA must be great. (Do correct me). And that usually ends up being tankies.

    He’s been outspoken on the genocide in Gaza, at least. Which is one of the USA’s proxy imperialist projects.

    USA, Russia, China, they’re all terrible in their own way. We don’t get to choose where we’re born.

    I’m a socialist (edit: not a “democratic socialist”, like actually a socialist who wants revolution and institution of a worker controlled society) in Australia. Am I okay with imperialism too because of Australia’s actions?

    In conclusion, Mamdani isn’t gonna bring about socialism, but he’s certainly not as bad as you’re describing (that I can tell, so far).