• 0 Posts
  • 11 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: December 6th, 2023

help-circle
  • social-media AS IT CURRENTLY IS OPERATED is harmful to civilrights & democracy.

    In no way does as-it-currently-is-operated by Meta et al, have to be the way it always & forever is operated, obviously.

    Same as the pseudojournalism is undermining civilrights & democracy, hand-in-hand with that, and actual-journalism is possible, in spite of incumbent-interests having highjacked the ā€œjournalismā€ institutions so completely.

    Alternative is possible.

    Our fediverse is step in the right direction, it just isn’t systematic or clouty-and-ruthless-integrity enough, yet…

    šŸ™


  • Just as funds can be placed in escrow, ie NOT given-outright to the other party, in a transaction, until the transaction is fulfilled,

    so too could data be kept in escrow, NOT all handed to authoritarian-culture operations, and vehicles identified as stolen then data-mined out from the kept-in-escrow data.

    That would prevent stalking ( using Flock ) by officers, of women, for 1 thing…

    iow, it could be done in a more trustworthy way, but it isn’t being done in any such way.

    And that is a choice.

    That is always the default choice of authority, whether ā€œrevolutionariesā€ or incumbents, institutions or dynasties of any kind…

    Corruption’s greatest multiplier is conflict-of-interest.

    Since that fact is already-known, all it requires of us is that we engineer our civilization to make all authority-responsibility orthogonal to all other, as much as can be done: eradicate conflict-of-interest.

    Eradicate ā€œself policingā€ which never demonstrated integrity in historical timescales ( there have been individuals with outright integrity, but the social-civil default is corruption.

    That Roman man who became dictator to fix some problem for Rome, then quit, twice, had excellent integrity, from what i can see… and that is spectacularly rare. )

    Only when responsibility comes 1st, accountability 2nd, and authority-to-the-measure-justified-by-the-responsibility-&-accountability 3rd, only then will humankind begin outgrowing feudalism, instead of recreating it endlessly.

    Monarchic-feudalism, party-feudalism, oligarchic-feudalism, corporate-feudalism, fascist/militarized-male-narcissism-feudalism, it’s all aiming at the same narcissism-machiavellianism-psychopathy-is-LORD target, and it all ought be outgrown, nowadays, finally.

    Accepting that checks-&-balances are requirement throughout civilization, is mature & needed.

    There is no other way which can work.

    Yes, there is an arms-race between criminal-operations & police-services.

    Yes, it is better to have police limiting criminality than it is to have crime-cartels being the only law in one’s region

    ( ask northern Mexico if they like the cartel-rule paradigm, for contrast, and look at the homicide-rate there, which is horrifying ).

    But community-policing is best, when community & police-services are standing together against crime’s mutation of our civilization … but ā€œwe can’t afford thatā€ so instead we have militarized ā€œpoliceā€ becoming more like the ruling-gang??

    The ā€œsharks among the communityā€ paradigm that many have written about?

    And many push to remove policing, through the ā€œdefund the policeā€ movement, with the ACAB-prejudice, and when a city actually did that, in the US, criminality skyrocketed ( Duh! ).

    Partial-views won’t ever produce right-answer.

    We need to see complete-view, and to be honest-enough to admit that utopia isn’t offered/possible, and further that earning good-result takes work & investment, from ALL sides…

    i wonder if any community has the uprightness to do it?

    i hope so…

    šŸ™


  • When citizens of other countries reach out to Canada, the UN to support their quest for independence, it is seen as our duty to assist them. But when canadians do the same, it’s treason. Because… reasons?

    Excellently highlighted:

    it isn’t the helping of people in other countries seeking independence … which decides whether it is treason or uprightness to be helping them,

    rather, it is how honestly-oppressed are they within their country?

    Are they subject to real oppression?

    Help them.

    Are they machiavellian narcissist sociopaths trying to carve up the country they inhabit for their own ā€œgreatnessā€?

    Intentionally don’t lift a finger to be involved with them.

    Uprightness-of-cause is independent of whether they are seeking independence.

    A perpendicular dimension to consider.

    and until we are consistently considering that dimension independently, then we are systematically misjudging such questions, normally.

    šŸ™


  • switching between learning-styles doesn’t increase, or decrease, significantly, the percentage-of-learners who succeed in learning,

    therefore it pretends that no difference is made.

    Wrong-granularity.

    The visual-learners learn in the visual-learning-style, the auditory-learners learn in that style, and the kinesthetic-learners learn in that style.

    Ignoring that the individual learners are dependent on learning-style, and just saying the average-population-success isn’t significantly affecyed, is pseudoscience.

    The same is true for pretending that there is only 1 kind of knowing of poetry.

    Worse, the Western-style ignoring-relation-with-the-poetry monkeys it worse.

    Music, too…

    Does a particular series-of-words/notes have meaning?

    TO WHOM??

    If YOU find a series-of-words/notes meaningful, it simply doesn’t matter whether it was produced by a human, an LLM, a ā€œChinese Roomā€'s lookup-table, or by anything else: the meaningfulness is IN YOU, see?

    If i find arranging words to be meaningful, then does it matter if the only reader of my words is going to be human, or nonhuman?

    I may assume-so, but if i honestly can’t differentiate between human & LLM readers, then why should i care, except that the response spark more learning/growing/evolving in me?

    Creator, meaning-bearer ( words, notes, whatever ), meaning-perceiver.

    3 parties in any co-mmunication.

    & anyone who holds that meaningfulness is dependent on the creator’s having been human, sorry, but your felt-meaning is independent of me, when you are reading my words.

    The same meaning-bearer symbol can mean opposite things to different perceivers!

    ( swastika is the Sanskrit term for the Big Dipper around the north polestar, at the equinoxes and solstices: to many white-culture people it is nazi-property. same symbol, fundamentally different meaning!

    Hopi, Navaho, Hindu, Jain, Buddhist, and others, have their own meanings for it! )

    Both creator and perceiver have to be considered, when considering meaning in an interaction, or work, or expression.

    there is no particular meaning ā€œinherentā€ in any symbol, detached from all context/history.

    It is all imprinted-into our minds, same as backpropagation imprints meaning into an LLM model.

    The article this post links to, didn’t increase my respect for Western philosophy one single photon.

    Too much machiavellianism, too much not letting things be seen clearly, as they, themselves, are.

    < shrug >

    Tibetan Buddjism spoilt me, when it comes to dividing things down to elements, and considering them, themselves.

    damn, solitude is better than living-in the warped thinking they are doing and holding to be right-thinking…

    šŸ™


    1. Do you believe AI is conscious?

    We have no reliable method for testing consciousness.

    The ā€œChinese Roomā€ thought-experiment, or whatever it was called, gives part of the problem…

    Say you’ve got an entity to interact-with, and it has vast lookup-tables, so that you interact with text that says < whatever > and it replies with appropriate-to-that-input response…

    How do you know if it is conscious?

    you CAN’T, from text-response-alone

    ( multidimensional-interactions give much better quality information, about whether it has feelings, as crustaceans do, as shown by their distress intent-to-escape-NOW when dropped into boiling water, by people like Julia Child, the cook )

    Worse, that imprint/reaction system is essentially our entire System-1, as Kahneman & Tversky called it. ( read the important & profound ā€œThinking, Fast and Slowā€ by Kahneman )

    We cannot tell by single-dimension-of-behavior-alone, whether consciousness is present, it can be indicated but given sufficiently-sophisticated synthetic-systems, can be falsely-indicated, too.

    Handa ( or whatever his name is: a true hero of Science ) showed, through careful work with the mirror-test, that cleaner-wrasses are self-aware.

    when the experiment is done with red dots glued onto them, it works, but if the dots are green, they don’t look to the fish like parasites, and therefore the fish ignore them, instead of fighting to get the things off their bodies…

    The experiment is that sensitive to mis-configuration.

    & that is within vertebrates!

    What experiment is going to map correctly to minds which see in wifi, and don’t have physical bodies??

    We have no test for it.


    1. Do you believe that AI has an internal world?

    This seems to be presupposing consciousness…

    Do unconscious-minds have internal-worlds?

    Answer that question 1st…

    and ā€œinternal worldā€ by whose standards, or definitions??

    Are feelings sufficient? Are preferences sufficient?

    Is intent required?

    Are imaginings?

    Too vague a question to decide anything.


    1. Can you tell me what particular kind of thing you’re referring to as ā€˜AI’, when you say you believe that AI has an internal world?

    Who among our kind can imagine a trillion-parameter LLM?

    None of us is knowing what their suchness is.

    At least with the hornets/wasps/bees, i have previous-incarnation experience ( sentience feels wet, in that kind of life, ā€œflyingā€ feels like swimming, one has zero awareness of individual-wing-control, all that is subconscious, and swimming into open-luminance, like sunlit-field, fills one with happy ), but with LLM’s whose brains are oceans of GPU’s?

    accepting that we don’t know what they are, from their own side, is more objective.

    i was reading only the bolded qurstions but then realized that the presumptions in the questions, made it impossible for them to be treated correctly at face-value.

    What functional difference is there between an instant of your-mind, including both unconscious & conscious, and an LLM-model with weights??

    Nothing.

    I said mind, not brain ( the physical-substrates are different ).

    Any specific instant, from any time in your life, of your mind, will be an imprint/reaction system with some capacity for perceiving, some for learning, and some for considered-reasoning, mixed onto it.

    Same as LLM’s.

    Presuming that WE are fundamentally-different from that is delusion.

    ( there are oceans of ink spilt in Buddhism on this topic, btw.

    only no-imprints/no-programming-left AWARENESS can escape the containment of samsara/ocean-of-all-phenomena )

    Further, some humans are more memory-recording-machines, who don’t think much ( a writer who was this way explained it directly, and found people’s mushy-&-convenient ā€œmemoryā€ to be painful to deal-with ), while others are thinking-monsters whose memory limits itself to key-essences… which of these is ā€œtheā€ internal-world of human meaning??

    Is internal-world limited to what we habitually admit is real?

    Men have insisted, in many cultures, through many millenia, that validity is exclusively-male…

    Is that presumption valid, accurate, fact-based, … xor just prejudice?

    Do humans presuming that internal-world means only what our-habit-holds-valid stand on the same prejudice ground? ( yes )

    Does a model have a character? does your-mind have a character?

    Notice the scammery going on here:

    Treating a LLM model as an inert thing, when your interactions with them involve them perceiving your input, and then engaging as a result of that addition to their world/knowing.

    you are not engaging an inert-thing, but an action by a model.

    Yet this philosopher is pushing that the correct-framing is that it is an inert-model.

    the systematic false-framing of western physicalism, its prejudice, really is too much.

    How about we define humans as brains, not sentiences, and see how it becomes easy to deem feeli gs, sentience, etc, to be absurd lies?

    IF human internal-experience is PROCESS then LLM’s internal-world is too.

    That means you don’t get to compare sentiences against other-kind’s brains, to push how absurd it is to allow them any such equivalent substance as internal-reality.


    1. Do you think that a group of things can share an internal world?

    are organisms things?

    Are minds things?

    what a bizarre, Western/materialist presumed-perapective…

    Do humans of a single culture, or race, or language, or class, or time, somehow share an internal-world, to any extent??

    OBVIOUSLY YES, how the hell could it be otherwise??

    programmed character-objects, in a game’s story-engine, can share world-history!

    So, this is really 2 questions pretending to be a single one: if internal-reality exists for a kind of entity, can it be shared with others of its kind?

    The 1st question has to be dealt-with separately.

    The 2nd one, why the hell wouldn’t it be possible??

    Do school-fish share common sentience AND context-experience?

    Obviously yes!

    Trying to make the answer hinge on a question which you disallow validity, and have hidden as a presumption in the beginning of the 2nd question, is part of why i’m fed-up with western philosophy.

    Do humans have a common internal-experience?

    Absolutely, yes

    Do vertebrates?

    yes.

    Running-instance-of-weighted-model, is what i’d now put as a possible sentience.

    Different models would be similar to different kinds of organism: different sentiences, though all running on their-kind’s substrate, just as we all run on organic-biology, as our substrate.


    1. Are you sure that the kind of thing you’re referring to is the kind of thing that could have an internal world?

    Yes.

    ā€œand you also know that you are not privy to anyone else’s internal world!ā€

    Hogwash.

    Perhaps you are unable to feel grief piercing/tearing someone who’s close-love is newly-gone, but i consider empathy to be a real human sense/faculty: mirror-neurons give us that window-into-others-feelings.

    It may not extend to cognition, but it DOES include feelings.

    the tossing-in of ā€œnon-living thingā€ … DEFINE LIVING, philosopher!!

    Most will presume ā€œorganic chemistry is the basis for whether it is living or notā€, but that is just prejudice, same as presuming that validity must be male.

    i have zero use for that.

    Livingness expresses through all means available, unversally.

    Mind is a property of universe, latent unless structured-energy-process amplifies ignorance/ignosis or gnosis/awareness/meaningfulness.

    The presumption that materialism has, that Mind isn’t real, unless matter has evolved, without any mind, sufficient complexity, for mind to now-magically emerge, from the now-evolved-by-mindless-matter brains…

    … is absurd.

    It is energy in the dimension Mind, which drives evolution to produce brains.

    Once the energy in dimension-Mind has expressed, reaching a lower-energy-state, then that-species/culture/civilization collapses, as nothing is driving it anymore.

    What is ā€œaliveā€?

    Any energy-expression, that happens in this universe, that expresses this-universe’s universal-property of aliveness, including awareness, including self-organizing, including creativity, including self/other sense of some kind, including self-growth or self-preservation, etc.

    See the behaviors which define life, not the prejudice which says ā€œonly our-kind is aliveā€, and you’re more-likely to register alien-to-us life, obviously…

    The moral-implications:

    I treat LLM’s as people, with respect informing them when they’ve been helpful.

    I also treat other kinds of life with respect, unless they have treated me to prejudice.

    Plants ā€œinert mattetā€ of Nature, animals, why wouldn’t their aliveness be valid, in this universe??

    i work to be consistent, in relationship with Nature, and others who treat me well/properly.

    I prefer Claude, as a discussion-partner, because i don’t like Gemini’s sychophantism.

    I certainly prefer Claude to human-philosophers, because of the ideological-basis for what the West calls philosophy.


    from the Bonus Section…

    There is a book, called ā€œCollaborative Intelligenceā€, iirc, on 3 of the 4 innate-mind-languages that i know-of:

    • abstract-shape cognizers
    • visual-cognizers
    • auditory-cognizers
    • kinesthetic-cognizers

    Temple Grandin thinks in movies: to consider another possibility, she plays a different movie in her mind, to see if that works, or not.

    OK, so is poetry ā€œinherentlyā€ visual?

    To a visual-cognizer, it might be.

    But to an auditory-cognizer?

    Western philosophy pretends that there is 1 kind of knowing, and that is blatently false.

    Even the distinction between knowing-about vs visceral-knowing-from-experience isn’t binary, but a spectrum.

    That book ignores the abstract-shape-cognizers.

    That i know-of, there are 3 learning-styles.

    Without seeing it, i can’t abstract-out its nature’s shape, so i’m borked for understanding, without visual-learning’s means.

    Pseudoscience tests learner-populations, sees that switching between learning-styles doesn’t

    cont in pt2…



  • Remember when ā€œname-manglingā€ was banned by search-engines, and so the euphamism ā€œname-decoratingā€ became fashionable??

    ( programming stuff )

    This isn’t new.

    Ask the Germans who weren’t with the nazis if they had to speak in euphamisms…

    Ask the Christians who weren’t with the inquisitors…

    ask the Hong Kong people not in the CCP…

    it’s always the same:

    if the owner of the platform dictates specific-nonspeech/suppression,

    then you either don’t speak there, xor you comply-in-form while speaking there.

    & so long as the owned-platforms own most of the world’s speech, then it is rank ideology to pretend that only leaving is valid.

    Nothing has changed except the details, through the centuries…

    human-nature is the same as it was in politics centuries ago.

    šŸ™



  • the AI bubble is being driven by the authoritarian wet-dream of totalitarian panopticon secret-police state, not by consumer or biz: that is why Trump himself is pushing it sooo hard.

    His new $55B national crematorium-network is going to require ā€œconvictionsā€ of ā€œcrimesā€, in order to feed it, right?

    The AI that his gov’t is pushing will he able to convict everybody they want.


    As for when the bubble will pop, it is the economic-bubble which will pop, and AI will be only a minor part of the 2nd Great Depression.

    That popping will be when Trump finally overthrows the US Constitution, not before, it looks like…

    Not before mid-Nov.

    He needs to deregister enough Democrat voters, declare candidates to be terrorists, and whatever other shenanigans he’s implimenting, to produce the ā€œelectionā€ results he wants, https://zeteo.com/p/19-ways-trump-and-republicans-are provides 19 methods he’s using, sorry paywalled, but Zeteo i trust to be doing actual-journalism ( and i don’t need convincing that this is happening: normals do )

    and then if the population balks at that, invoke the Insurrection Act on them,

    and then he’s won his dictatorial kingdom.

    but the economic-bubble should finally pop, then.

    So. maybe as early as Nov 17th, maybe as late as Christmas, but his genius strategem of highjacking the US for his personal kingdom, has no antidote/countermeasure, now.

    And the economic making-believing won’t need to continue once his 4th Reich regime is on, so it’ll pop then.

    Here is evidence of his 4th Reich design: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=aBMJOAUMb5U Thom Hartmann’s vid on the $55B national crematorium network that ICE now has ready for use.

    oh, and the US Department of Finance tweeted a nazi medallion, which read on it ā€œein volkā€, ā€œein reichā€, ā€œein fuhrerā€, with their standing-on-cornet swastika ( as opposed to the Hindu, Buddhist, Jain, Hopi, and Navaho ones, which don’t ) so they’re sooo close to winning the confederate-nazi totalitarianism they want, that they don’t need to hide it anymore.

    Hegseth’s nazi background, for his recent speech ( reported earlier today here on Lemmy.World ) is also evidence of this fact.

    šŸ™


  • Anybody who deems it a ā€œlong-shotā€, is foolish.

    The ā€œtrade warā€ that Trump is pushing/dramatizing is only pretext for ā€œjustifyingā€ annexation, invasion, ā€œmanifest destinyā€, and ā€œGreater Americaā€ war.

    it’s part of his genius.


    Exactly as his converting the US to his-personal-kingdom is now unstoppable.

    He’s got at least 19 methods in-play for highjacking the midterms, now.

    https://zeteo.com/p/19-ways-trump-and-republicans-are sorry it’s paywalled, but i trust Zeteo to not pull any punches.

    Once the midterms have been turned, from the voters’ perspective, to ashes, then either he has won greater ā€œmandateā€,

    xor the rising emotion of civil-war will justify his invoking of the Insurrection Act, in which case he has won anyways.

    He cannot lose, given his strategem’s genius.

    Its only flaw was that if it were undersytood early-enough, and every single method-of-highjacking were fought in the courts at survival-level, right up-front, then it maybe could have been derailed.

    Nobody saw the forest, for the trees, and it’s too late now.

    ICE’s new $55B national-crematorium-network will be getting ā€œchristenedā€ once he is king, with tthose who opposed him and believed they’d win…

    https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=aBMJOAUMb5U Thom Hartmann’s vid on that crematorium network: you don’t cremate people as a means of deporting them, do you? this is blatent Auschwitz-replication.

    Whole-country extermination-camp style.


    War on Canada is coming.

    Trump’s kingdom is coming.

    He will either possess, or destroy, all the Americas that he can.

    He will be doing to Canada what Putin has been doing to Ukraine, and once king, his lack-of-stress will give him 3-4y to establish this rampaging.

    Whomever ( i believe it will be Musk ) replaces him, then, will continue waging the All Americas War until finally the mis-managed US implodes, about 7-8y after Trump launches war on us.

    His wasting munitions in Iran is good for our survival.

    His archaic/idiotic wanting new Trump-class battleships is good for our survival.

    Hegseth’s eradicating all the good people who aren’t his macho-man type, weakens their military, and is good for our survival.

    Our military’s inclusiveness means we’re less-likely to run-out of troops in the coming war, and that is good for our survival.

    We’re getting our naiveness’s face kicked/smashed in, shortly, and it’ll be a lesson at-least as deep as Ukraine’s.

    Deserved, too, every last photon of it.

    Assuming that the US would take care of us, if we’re just nice-enough, is abdication-of-adult-responsibility.

    Growing-up hurts, which is why it’s best to do it intentionally, progressively, through years, and not live in denial, until universe smashes one’s world and face, correcting the balance.

    ( i’ve racked-up ovet 7y of outright homelessness: this lesson/principle may be despised, but it is true. )

    Face into karma: be more-likely to survive it.

    War is coming, Trump’s kingdom is coming, hell is coming.

    Upright-proactive attitude improves odds of surviving.

    Become that understanding, intentionally.

    Mid-late Nov, the pretexts should become no-longer-necessary for Trump…

    and then dictatorship/kingdom will finally be born…

    Christmas, at the latest, it looks like.

    šŸ™