
Login-walled

Login-walled


Okay and how would you get that private key?
By having access to an unlocked device: which means you also have access to all messages. Therefor this attack vector is not as big a deal as you are making it.


I’m saying those others that pretend to implement pfs, still leak all chats the user didn’t delete (and in some cases even then) when an attacker has access to the private key because that’s stored in the same database.


Yes and I’m saying that since the only way to get access to that private key on delta chat is to get access to an unlocked device at which point you have access to all the messages on that device anyway (on signal too)


I think anonymous messenger generally means talking to other people anonymously. If I want to talk to my friend from school that is private messaging, but that shouldn’t require me to identify myself to some foreign company.


Delta chat assumes the relays are evil and of course doesn’t send private keys there


Just don’t allow easily guessable identifiers


Forward secrecy protects against intercepting now and decrypting later when you get access to the users private key: this is only possible on delta chat if you get access to the client database at which point you can read all undeleted messages anyway. (On Signal even deleted messages!)


Yes that’s the point of requiring payment or a phone number


the servers aren’t all located within US borders
The US servers are required (see us-west outage crashing Signal globally)


There is no evidence that having Signal infrastructure hosted on US company servers provides any capacity for the US government to bypass Signal’s encryption.
I didn’t say that. A foreign government being able to disable your communication whenever they want to is already a threat to national security


and then the government ends up using Signal internally anyway
Which is terrible for national security because everything is hosted on centralized American servers
So you complain about the walled garden but the wall is actually a moat you dug yourself?
The AI bailout already happened, the US government is pumping infinite money into it through their military arm.