• 0 Posts
  • 26 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: February 22nd, 2024

help-circle



  • I like the accountability angle. While this is powerful, I’m not so sure about the entire premise of your remaining argument.

    Specifically, you note Republicans can easily defund programs, while Democrats need 60 votes to establish them. But eliminating or reducing funding is not always the same as repealing a program.

    For example, a future Republican majority might want to:

    • Repeal environmental regulations
    • Eliminate federal labor protections
    • Rewrite civil-rights statutes
    • Restructure immigration law
    • Create national voting restrictions
    • Repeal programs which cannot be changed through reconciliation

    The filibuster doesn’t just determine which policies can be enacted; it affects how easily every subsequent majority can reverse them.

    Bottom line: If Democrats could enact their entire agenda with 51 Senate votes, would they accept Republicans having exactly the same power in two years?

















  • People today are too far gone from the reality of our situation to understand this. Democracy is only meant to prevent killing one another en masse, as a means to say who would probably win in a war. That’s the very basis of its design.

    Think about it. Think of human history. And why is the cutoff exactly >50%? Strength means victory- if not a pyrrhic one.

    If you aren’t even willing to vote for your beliefs, you certainly aren’t willing to pickup a rifle. The other side still will.