Just a corn on the internet.

Lemmy stores DMs in plain text. If that’s an issue for you, use the matrix contact @einkorn:tchncs.de for encrypted chats.

🇩🇪 DE/EN 🇬🇧

  • 2 Posts
  • 54 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 21st, 2024

help-circle

















  • what the heck is the point of all the armor then?

    Same as before: To keep the vehicle operational under fire. Now it just has less meat sacks to protect.

    […] it is way more fiddly and tenuous [to] properly control the vehicle when under jamming and wartime conditions […]

    Are you under the impression that in modern SPGs there are still people cranking some gears to aim the device? It’s all electronics anyways.

    The task of artillery is to fire indirectly at predetermined targets. Compared to a FPV drone the only live information the system needs to do this is target coordinates. Unless there is 24/7 100% effective jamming going on, a brief window is all that is needed to transmit those. And no, jamming causing coordinates to be scrambled is not an issue. The problem of transmitting complete data in unstable environments has been solved ages ago. Every other parameter to create a target solution can be determined locally.

    If there is heavy jamming a human crew can’t operate the SPG from inside its armored body either: Artillery is indirect fire, without visual contact or communications there is nothing to shoot at. An unmanned/automated system even has an advantage in this case: Transmitting human language is highly inefficient compared to textbased information. So it can make better use of short windows of communication.

    And as for reliability in wartime conditions: The whole premise of unmanned vehicles is that they can be abandoned if needed without having to spend time and effort to recover valuable crew. Yes, they are going to break down. So what? Send in the next one and mark the old one down for pickup at a later date when the area is cleared of hostiles.

    …and now you have to armor and protect the location the crew are remotely operating the vehicle from anyways so?

    Unmanned vehicles can be controlled at any given range depending on the circumstances: If there is no jamming going on, the operator can sit thousands of kilometers away at an office desk or meters below ground in a bunker.

    If there is no communications, as I wrote previously the whole concept of artillery is breaking down anyway.