• 0 Posts
  • 60 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: March 31st, 2025

help-circle

  • No, it’s a statistically sound question, the answer to which is essential to have a meaningful understanding of the statistics. If AI image generation went up 100000% in the same time, that means a smaller proportion of users are making CSAM, which could tell us something about a change in audience for AI. On the other hand, if general image generation went up 10%, then this would mean many users have started making CSAM that weren’t before, or that the users who were making it are now making much more. And all of this really depends further on the ratio beforehand. A percent increase is just not a very meaningful way to report this important information.

    We should always encourage asking logical and scientific questions about things, even (in fact, especially) when the face-value interpretation aligns with our existing understanding. “Percentage increase” reports are famously capable of being misleading.

    Lastly, “whataboutism” is often used incorrectly, due to its unfortunate name, people think that any time someone’s question or issue might be phraseable as “what about XYZ”, that that’s whataboutism. But it really, really isn’t. Please read this https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whataboutism , because I fear that the confusing terminology may be steering you wrongly.



  • The tariffs helped at least some rich people (you can tell because that’s the only reason Trump doss anything). The rich don’t have perfect class solidarity indeed, so it comes down to who is most powerful and doing the most winning. And its true Huang also most likely made some people richer in doing this, but they were in a different country and therefore less able to protect him. Big mistake to enrich the people who don’t have legal jurisdiction over you at the expense of people who do




  • I used to think that, too. But lately, I’ve started to consider that even more people are even worse drivers than I thought. And I think that really changes things.

    Also, that common airplane statistic about deaths is usually reported in terms of passenger miles, which I think is a little misleading since airplanes intrinsically travel many more miles. It would be more meaningful to measure deaths per trip or better yet deaths per passenger hour rather than miles. However, I did find some lawyer websites saying that the lifetime odds of dying in a plane crash are around 1 in 800,000,000 versus 1 in 95 for cars.

    Now I know it seems deranged on the face of it, but hear me out.

    For driving to be as safe as flying, we would need someone to be about 8500 times less likely to die over the course of their life driving. Most people drive 5 days a week, for about 50 years, so 13000 days driving. So:

    The odds of surviving a day of safe driving= S

    Odds of surviving a day of dangerous driving= D

    8500=S^13000 / D^13000 = (S/D)^13000

    S/D = 8500^(1/13000) = 1.0007

    So if driving safer on day made you even 0.07% more likely to survive that day, then that gives us that 8500x increase over a lifetime.

    Now…I know this is based on that 1/95 which ALREADY includes the safe drivers. So the legitimacy of this estimate depends on how many drivers you think are safe. This is why my estimate of that ratio caused me to change my mind. I feel like only around 15% of people drive at that level of safety. So, of course, in some sense this still means that driving in general is more dangerous because you have an 85% chance of being one of the people for whom it is more dangerous. But I still think there’s something to be said for the minority of truly cautious and defensive drivers.

    Acknowledging other failure points here, most airplane deaths are in private aviation, so that may make the bar harder to clear again. But I think the whole 13000 days estimate demonstrates how even tiny improvements there can easily account for large changes, too.


  • mfed1122@discuss.tchncs.detoMicroblog Memes@lemmy.world•Any final thoughts?
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    33
    arrow-down
    5
    ·
    7 days ago

    Respect to both you and your friend for being logically consistent just at different risk thresholds.

    However, I will add that it’s not certain whether the risk level of driving is equal for good or bad drivers. It’s not exactly an illusion of control. You really do have more control. If it were somehow possible to reliably separate people who died in a car into groups of people that were driving responsibly versus not driving responsibly, I don’t know if that would look as dangerous as an airplane or not… But it seems fair to estimate that it wouldn’t be.



  • mfed1122@discuss.tchncs.detoLinux@lemmy.ml•Cuck License
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    11
    ·
    9 days ago

    How specific can licenses really get? Would it be possible to update the license on a version update of an existing library to for instance specifically forbid Fortune 1000 companies from using it, but everyone else can? It would be amazing to see these places get their tech stacks ripped out from under them, although of course many would just illegally use the code and never tell