• 1 Post
  • 11 Comments
Joined 2 months ago
cake
Cake day: September 28th, 2026

help-circle
  • Excellent summary and one of my favorite topics in economics. I want to add one tidbit: In the 1950s and 1960s, the US had the highest sustained rate of GDP-per-capita growth in its history, launching it to superpower and creating the broad middle class. There was a 90% tax rate on income above an inflation-adjusted equivalent of about $10m/year. The massive inflation caused by the Oil Embargo hit, and the income level of that 90% rate was not adjusted upward with inflation. In fact, the level had not been adjusted since FDR. By the late 1970s, that 90% rate was hitting regular Joe Entrepreneurs, and putting a real bind on small business growth. Instead of adjusting the threshold, the tax rate was cut (first under Carter, sadly).

    As you note, that loose money at the top stimulated the economy and tossed a lit match under Wall Street. Reagan took credit for it and used it as evidence to cut the top tax rate much further (Voodoo economics / Laffer). It was a coincidence and a short-term benefit, and that low top rate - the lack of friction on extreme incomes - has been causing wealth concentration and preventing GDP from flowing to the middle class ever since.

    Piketty, Saez, and Zucman are three excellent economists at Berkeley and The Paris School of Economics who have been doing detailed research on it and screaming it at the top of their lungs for 20 years.

    Edit: Capital gains and tax avoidance have now become a much more pervasive way of accelerating the problem. Meaning it can can no longer be solved merely by adjusting the top marginal threshold and rate.




  • 100% - stop imagining. Go do it.

    Get a $10 tin whistle, spend 15 minutes a day for one month practicing, go on a hike. At the top of the mountain / hill / in a field / near a brook - pull out the whistle and play “Black Velvet Band.” You may have to dance around a bit to get others to figure out WTF you’re on about, but they’ll join in. And they’ll tell the story for ages, hoping you come on the next hike.






  • I agree. It is hard, sometimes, to criticize a thing without referencing it. I think the moderators should have the latitude to decide when the value of a critique rises above the cost of presenting the very thing that this community exists to criticize.

    It will be inherently subjective and case-by-case, regardless of how the rule is worded. I think that means our job is to report things we think are wrong, and do our best to trust and respect the moderators who have to make the tough calls.




  • Your disgust is valid. But the developer generally has no gall, and no agency. The corporation tells them to pack and monetize the clickthroughs like feeding puppies into a sausage machine. The developer never thought that would be the job.

    In fact, every time you don’t see something like this, it’s because some developer said, “Enough, I won’t do this,” putting their job (and their next rent payment) on the line. I lost two jobs that way.

    Don’t let them divide us. The fascist oligarchs are the villains.