The vehicles in question, because the article doesn’t show both:


The resemblance is pretty vague, if you said “The chinese Landrover” I’d know what you meant, but I don’t think anyone would mistake one for the other, it looks like this is just a pretext for protectionism.
Eh, it’s just the headlights and parts of the front.
The rest looks very similar. A little taller, scaled down fenders and that’s largely it I think?
Other than being boxy, some of the lines, that panel in the backseat window, and the rims, everything is completely different, wheelwells, different hood geometry, the windshield is a different angle, the mirror, pillar, and roof all have different colors, the chinese one has smaller wheels and bigger tires,
Fuck the article for not showing a comparison picture and thank you for that. I feel that we here are seeing a “form follows function” thing. Both cars are trying to be as boxy as possible because that kind of car looks like that.
One of the pieces of plastic bullshit in the pictures is a modern Land Rover Defender? They could have done the decent thing and just banned both. Nobody needs those garbage cars.
I think the accusation is that BYD started from the Land Rover design and made changes until it looked “different enough” like a student copying homework. That’s a big no-no if proven.
That’s basically impossible to prove unless someone from the design team snitches on themselves?
And probably not the actual line given how many other cars were openly designed that way, famously the Miata was based off the Lotus Elan.
There were raids in BYD offices in Europe. Maybe someone was stupid enough to leave a paper trail.
It was released in China and other markets a year before it hit Europe, a judge ordered the documents seized destroyed.
Do I think they took apart a Landrover and then modified things until they were different/suited to existing manufacturing means? Yes.
Do I think the raid expected to find evidence of this? No, since it wasn’t designed in europe, the raid and judgement was simply to prevent chinese competition.
Neither of them looks like a defender to me, tbh. Where’s the right angles? The little window on the side of the roof?
Both cars depicted look like a bunch of plastic garbage glued together, with 4 wheels stuck on, not like a robust no compromises off-road vehicle. Neither is a Land Rover Defender.
Is it modern single-production-line-multiple-trims mass production that makes it difficult for cars to have interesting lines?
I don’t think Landrover has been offroad-first, everything else second for decades, its just another luxury SUV.
It’s not about bullshit like “having interesting lines”.
The Land Rover Defender used to be one of the most utilitarian cars out there. Built for a very specific niche, and very good in it. Whatever is shown in those pictures is not that, it’s just another useless douchemobile made out of plastic garbage that serves no other purpose any other car couldn’t serve as well.
the original Defender was shitballed for good reason.
https://33gears.com/land-rover-discontinued-models/#defender
Land Rover ended production in January 2016 for a blunt reason: the old Defender could not meet modern pedestrian-impact, crash-safety, and emissions standards without a ground-up redesign.
The all-new Defender (L663) arrived in 2020 — a fully modern, monocoque, computerized SUV that’s wildly capable but shares almost nothing mechanically with the original.
When was that? Certainly not in my lifetime.
I thought the UK government had banned people that young using the internet ?
And that’s why enshittification is so successful. People don’t look back into the past very far, and therefore have no idea what they have lost.
I don’t think this is an example of enshitfication as much as gentrification. Same way Rolex switched from targeting working class people who needed a cheap, rugged watch to luxury branding, you went from a customer base where most of your money comes from people sensitive to offroad functionality, ease of maintaince, and price to one sensitive to looks and highway performance.
Its regulations, about crashworthiness and pedestrian safety, alongside fuel economy standards.
Isn’t LandRover a Tata (India) brand?
But we can’t ban American huge pickup trucks, why?
Should’ve banned both
doesn’t cars mostly look the same now in their category?
Either way, fuck cars.
Here’s the full court ruling (in Dutch): https://uitspraken.rechtspraak.nl/details?id=ECLI%3ANL%3ARBDHA%3A2026%3A34365








